Stephen and family
Peer to peer

Case study: We meet up with lender Stephen

Stephen is a 44-year old mortgage adviser, and currently resides in the Highlands of Scotland in Inverness-shire with his wife and son. He has been in the financial services industry for over two decades, although has been self-employed for the last 16 years. As a keen and knowledgeable investor, peer-to-peer lending is something that he began to look into a few years ago. We caught up with him to hear about his thoughts and experiences regarding P2P and all things finance…

Stephen's profile

Discovering peer-to-peer lending

I do like to have a look at what investments/savings are out there from time to time, and have dabbled in all sorts of things from fairly complex structured bonds to a couple of barrels of malt whisky. Even if that one doesn’t make a good profit, I can drown my sorrows pretty well at the end of the day!

But in all seriousness, I had become frustrated for years with sub-inflation returns from bank savings accounts, and the manic nature of stock market investing (which for myself, at least, tended to result in sizeable losses). Having come across it online and in various associated articles, I decided to look more closely into peer-to-peer lending a few years ago.

I soon realised that the risk/reward balance was impossible to beat. I now have over half my savings in P2P, and have to admit to enjoying seeing my balances increase steadily each month.

Dealing with risk, and some advice

Initially, I was slightly wary about the concept of P2P lending, but I was soon very encouraged to learn about some providers’ risk-minimising techniques such as provisions funds and thorough credit checks. 

For me, the risk aspect is something that I am comfortable with. I appreciated that for peer to peer lending to go ‘wrong’, it would require a serious meltdown of the UK economy. Something like a very deep recession or world war-type scenario. Nothing is impossible of course, but most non-cash investments would be compromised in a similar way with the same extreme conditions.

My advice to anyone considering P2P lending would be that, if you are unsure initially for any reason, try it out with a modest sum to get a feel for how it works; then, when more confident, build from there. But always keep a decent spread of investments all round.

Bear in mind though that although cash holdings in a bank, for example, are deemed to be ‘super safe’, in my book they have an almost guaranteed risk of losing money in real terms over time. They tend not to keep pace with inflation and you constantly have to keep a diary for when your incentive rates are ending. It’s a lot of work for very little return.

Impact of Brexit on P2P and the economy

Overall, I see, ‘Brexit’ having a slightly negative affect on what rates I can get from peer to peer, just the same as bank accounts. Lower rates on the back of a feared slower economy feeds into what returns you can get from a lending point of view.

It can be argued that lower interest rates are better news for shares as company debts are cheaper to service, which in turn leads to higher profits. But this argument may be offset against lower expected earnings on the back of economic uncertainty, and in my personal experience, I have not had a happy time of it investing in shares over the years - whatever the prevailing rate of interest!

Innovative Finance ISA and taking advantage of tax efficiencies in P2P

As someone who invests in P2P, the ISA is obviously an exciting prospect, and any tax saved will be most welcome for sure. I will be slowly transferring my maturing Cash ISAs’s to peer to peer ISA’s when they mature. I may as well save the most tax from the source that pays me the most interest!

I can see myself having up to 60% of my investments in peer to peer after the introduction of the ISA, and I will be keen to slowly flush out my non-ISA peer to peer holdings over time to have as much tax free as possible.

Looking ahead to retirement

I can honestly say that I am intending on using my P2P investments to help me retire much earlier than I would previously have thought possible. Aside from financial security, I want my golden years to be filled with plenty of travel and leisure.

I have been lucky to travel a fair bit over the years and have seen some amazing places. But to be honest, the day I do retire, I will probably spend that day out on my mountain bike, having a round of golf, or climbing a Scottish mountain. Something simple that I struggle to find enough time doing when I’m working so much!

My wife and I also fancy taking time to hire a campervan and touring down through the whole of Spain, checking out some of the lovely small towns and villages along the way. Three to four weeks would be nice, rather than the usual two weeks max before dashing back for work commitments!

Related articles:

Our website offers information about saving, investing, tax and other financial matters, but not personal advice. If you're not sure whether peer-to-peer lending is right for you, please seek independent financial advice, and if you decide to invest with Lending Works, please read our Key Lender Information PDF first.

As with all investments, your capital is at risk.